My ‘new’ HF aerial – A SteppIR UrbanBeam

This post has been a long time coming, regular readers may remember that back in March 2023 I made a comment that I’d decided what aerial I was going to buy and then I posted in April 2023 to say that I’d had deliveries but I’ve barely mentioned it since.

As per the printed sheets which came with the aerial, I downloaded the latest version of the assembly instructions and started building. I had noticed I was missing some parts so I contacted the supplier who was able to send them to me.

I completed the two element housing units (EHUs) and fitted them to the boom indoors and then it was time to schedule the assembly of the rest of the aerial.

The first thing was to lower the mast, remove the Hexbeam and fit the NN4ZZ tilt plate, this was done in the middle of July 2023 and then a week later, my brother came to help me do the rest of the work. We scheduled an entire weekend for this as it would involve removing my existing coax, replacing it with a run of new Hyperflex 10, building the rest of the aerial, mounting it to the mast and raising it back up.

This was where the problems started. The instructions I’d got didn’t quite seem to match up with all the parts. We got as far as we could and simply had to abort the work. There followed a long email conversation with me and SteppIR regarding construction and it became clear that the design had changed slightly between the version of the aerial I’d bought, and the instructions I’d downloaded. The exact build procedure was clarified and three weeks later, we tried again.

This time we were successful, the aerial build was completed and finally we managed to get it installed on the mast and raised into the air.

Here it is on the day it went up, the 19th August 2023.

Initial testing appeared to be good but within a couple of hours, it became clear that things weren’t quite right. I started getting some errors on the controller screen suggesting that there were issues with the controller cable.

Resolving this became quite a complicated affair involving a lot of testing, checking, retesting, rechecking. I remade all the terminations and replaced all the connectors but the error still persisted, albeit intermittently. I bought a SteppIRtest ONE to simplify testing and that really made things easier.

I also discovered that there was a fault on one of the EHUs that had been there since the beginning and so that unit was replaced under warranty by SteppIR. You can hear what the problem was by watching this video.

It was determined that this faulty EHU had blown some driver chips in the controller so again, these were replaced under warranty by SteppIR and my supplier. However, I was still intermittently getting the same error message I’ve posted above.

My work around for this was to only have the controller plugged in and switched on when I needed to adjust the aerial. In practise this was a pain because each time I wanted to change band, or even just retune within the same band, I’d need to plug the controller into the mains, switch it on, make the change, switch it off and then unplug it. It became quite a chore and although it avoided any more driver chip issues, I wasn’t happy with it.

I decided to swap the cable again between the junction box and the EHU. I’d already done this once but I’d used the same cable that was originally supplied. I bought some different cable and my brother came along to help again at the end of August 2024. The cable I’d bought was eight core so we decided to double up on each connection.

I’m very pleased to say that in the eight months or so since swapping this, I’ve not had any further instances of the error message on the controller or any more driver modules failing. I can only assume that there was a fault on the original cable that caused this and that fault must have been on the whole length of the cable because I’d already swapped it once.

It took a long time and a lot of work to finally get a fully working aerial. I can now leave the controller all plugged in and switched on with no fear of the fault reoccurring. I’ve used the aerial successfully for a number of contests and can easily run full power for extended periods with no issues whatsoever.

And I think it looks quite good too.

2 Comments

Add a Comment
  1. Marc Tielemans

    Hi, sorry to hear you had all those problems. I also have a hexbeam and am intrigued why you felt the need to change it for this antenna. I’m very happy with my hexbeam, are you seeing a significantly better performance?

    Marc
    M0KYB / M1T

    1. Hey Marc,

      I’ve had two Hexbeams now, the first one was quite an early one from the supplier and because of how I was using it, it had a habit of melting the cords between the two elements. Over the years I had it, the manufacturer made many modifications and e eventually came up with a fix which worked. But it had been through so many tweaks that I decided to replace it. A friend was selling his Hexbeam which I bought from him. Unbeknownst to me, he’d never assembled it correctly so when he helped put it up here, it still wasn’t assembled correctly and after a couple of years, it got very badly broken in a storm.

      Have a look at this blog entry here: https://qso365.co.uk/2020/07/broken-hexbeam-worst-aerial-damage-ive-had/

      But even after that repair, it was never quite right. At the slightest levels of wind, the VSWR was all over the place and I had quite a few instances where the elements snapped as they fed into the centre post. I’d done everything the manufacturer suggested but it was still just unreliable and that’s why I decided to replace it.

      If you’re interested, there’s a whole category for broken aerials on my blog: https://qso365.co.uk/category/broken-aerial/page/2/

      As for performance of the SteppIR against the Hex. In theory, they’re very similar aerials as they’re both two elements on each band (except 40m and 30m). I would say forward gain appears pretty much the same between them but the front to back ratio feels far greater on the SteppIR than the Hex and the forward beamwidth feels a little tighter. I definitely notice bigger nulls as I rotate it.

      Of course, a great feature on the SteppIR is the 180° button on the controller and I’ve found that really helpful in determining whether a signal is going to be better long path.

      It’s also nice to have a rotary dipole for 30m as well as 40m.

      Hope that helps to explain why I picked this as a replacement for the Hex.

      73 Keith.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.